You are currently browsing the tag archive for the ‘Covid 19’ tag.

Legion at the Lake: Crowds pack Lake of the Ozarks amid pandemic

The young people (those younger than me) call Covid-19 “the ‘rona.” As in, I think he has the ‘rona. Or, to be more specific, If you were in “Lake of the Ozarks” Missouri at the pool party where 400 strangers gathered (pictured above), you had a 1 in 3 chance of catching the ‘rona if your were coughed on by a ‘rona infected person.  Pool parties are known for spreading Covid. This should deter people. However, apparently this Memorial Day weekend the water is just too enticing

Jodi Akins, from Blue Springs, told CNN in a message that she visited the bar with four friends for a pool party on Saturday.
“When we walked up my first words were ‘oh my gosh’ it was intense for sure!! Social distancing was nonexistent. However everyone was enjoying themselves. It was a very carefree environment but security was heavy!!” she wrote to CNN.

We are all tired of the ‘rona. What’s  more, many of us are convinced we have already had the ‘roma. The conversation goes something “Remember when I had that little cough? That was it, let’s go to the beach.” Unfortunately, the science is not behind you. Here is Mobile, we mostly test for symptoms. People call up and say, to paraphrase, “I think I got the ‘rona.” They are then brought to an outdoor testing site where they are tested for ‘rona. Guess what…8 in 10 who believe they have it do not. They have some onther pesky viral infection. We also test people who are going in for routine medical procedures Guess how many of those folks have it….1 in 200. We also test antibodies  (markers in the blood for a current or past infection) for various reasons. Guess how many people have evidence that they had a known infection? Less than 1 in 20. And most of those who were infected worked or lived in nursing home or other group facility.

Why so few? Because social distancing worked. All the restaurants you didn’t go to. All the weddings you missed. All the church hymn sings that didn’t happen. This is how the spread stopped.  It turns out that mostly, the ‘rona spreads like this: Person A, for whatever reason, has a lot of ‘rona and doesn’t know it. This might be because they work at a nursing home and were taking care of a dying patient who was never tested but had a lot of ‘rona. It might be because they are gonna get really sick but it is still early.  It might be because, well,  they are just one of those people….Anyway, they show up at the pool party. Grab an adult beverage and get waist deep in the shallow end.. Cough on 15 people. 11 people don’t get it. Why not? Didn’t get inside of them. 4 people get the ‘rona. But, see, they don’t know it for 2 days. They go home to their family and cough on them. Of the 4 people in the house, 2 people get it. One just sucks it up and powers through. The other, an older man with hypertension and lung problems, ends up in the hospital and possibly dead.

Second problem. One of the other people hanging out at the pool who gets a ‘rona lugie to the face really doesn’t get sick and works in a grocery store, stocking the shelves. He works side by side with someone who is older and has some lung problems. A little cough (no mask ’cause they are for sissies) and 3 days later this guy’s sick. 100 grocery “heros” have died this way.

So, here are the facts: 1) You are still capable of getting the ‘rona and spread it to others with 95% certainty. 2) You might have the ‘rona now and don’t even know it ‘CAUSE YOU DIDN”T HAVE IT BEFORE. 3) You might be a super spreader and, in a crowd, could be responsible for multiple people dying which I am certain you do not want to do. 3) You could get it from a superspreader  at a crowded event and be responsible for the death of a family member or coworker, which I am certain you do not want to do. 4) You are lonely, bored and want to GET OUT.

Assuming you are young, not as selfish as some of your friends, and don’t want to actually kill someone, here are some suggestions for how to SAFELY hang out with folks on Memorial Day and beyond until we get a vaccine:

Pick your guests wisely – Don’t have people leave the Lake of the Ozarks pool party only to come to yours. Mostly stick to careful family and friends. Ask them if they have been careful. Limit to under 10 if possible and under 25 for certain.

Pick your space wisely – STAY OUTSIDE. Their have, to date, been no superspreader events outside. Eat with your quarantine unit. Do not spend a lot of close contact with folks you have not already been with. Remember that hand washing is very important as are disposable plates and utensils.

Avoid sharing covered dishes – The grilled meats, almost certainly ok, especially if you take them off the grill yourself. Aunt Rita’s carrot and raisin salad made with mayonnaise and lots of love? Possibly Covid-central. Each unit needs to bring their own sides. Also, no chips and dip. You ever watch folk eat that…

Practice social distancing – If you know that Uncle Harry sprays when he talks, stay 6-10 feet away and wear a mask. Better yet, tell him to wear a mask. When he goes all Fox News on you and says “where’s the evidence” you can either pull out your phone and show him studies OR you can ask him “where’s the evidence that hydroxychloriquine actually doesn’t kill people with the ‘rona OR you can do as I recommend and stay 30 feet away.  Especially avoid the crowd in the corner doing tequila shots as, aside from being inside, the other constant in superspreader events is booze.

Let folks burn off steam – Kids need to go outside and play. They are not proving to be the little bags on “rona we thought they were. Having said that, any child with a fever or a cough should be kept at home. Try to avoid games where spit is shared such as tackle football. In the pool, remember the 6 to 10 foot rule regarding strangers.

Afterwards, let the sun do the work – While everyone should pick up their own trash, leave the chairs and the tables. A couple of hours in the sun and the ‘rona is gone.

So, go outside, have fun, avoid strangers, and don’t kill any co-workers. Hopefully we can find a happy place between desolate isolation and 2,000,000 deaths soon.

 

Patient: I know I already had the Covid. Remember when I was so sick in January? Couldn’t breathe without coughing, so weak? THAT was the Covid, I’m sure. 

Me: No, it wasn’t. Covid didn’t move from the bats to people until late 2019 and it really wasn’t here in Mobile. I think that was probably the flu

Patient: But the test said it wasn’t. Did you test me for the Covid? I’m sure I had it.

Me: No, we didn’t have tests yet in this country. But the flu test could have been wrong

Patient: Wait, you ordered the wrong test on me???

Testing in healthcare is rather more complex than one might think. Folks come to me as a physician and want a diagnosis. I order a test and then say “Have you had it before?” When they say yes I say “Well ya got it again.” Not really. Actually, before I order the test I need to know a lot of stuff, otherwise the results will not be useful.

The first thing I need to know is how the test “performs.” Take a pregnancy test, for example. What the over-the-counter pregnancy tests measure is a chemical produced by the body in early pregnancy. In order to be more accurate, it only detects a level that is consistent with a 3 1/2 week pregnancy. So if a woman gets up, has sex, and uses a pregnancy test to see if she is pregnant, the answer will be “Not Pregnant” even though she is “maybe” pregnant. Also, late in the pregnancy, the chemical goes away in some woman, So if a woman has gained 30 pounds and feels something inside her kicking and moving, and has an ultrasound showing a baby she is “pregnant” despite the negative test. The number of times the test accurately detects the condition (in this case pregnancy between 3 1/2 and 15 weeks) is known as the positive predictive value (98%) and the number of times it accurately tells woman “not pregnant” is known as the negative predictive value (95%).

The other thing is that if there is a lot of disease, a positive test is more likely to be a “true positive.” If there is little disease, a negative test is more likely to be a “true negative.” So, if you do a pregnancy test on a woman who has had a hysterectomy, a positive is almost certainly not a pregnancy and is a “false positive.” Conversely, if the young woman pours water on the strip because she doesn’t want her mom to know she is having sex, the negative is almost certainly a “false negative.” Here is a really good video explanation.

What, you say, does this have to do with Covid-19? Currently, there is  controversy over testing. Initially, in this country, there were no tests. In the absence of tests, all the doctors and patients had was their clinical intuition. This works really well in flu season EVERYONE in the house has the flu and then MOM gets sick (OH MY GOD, WHAT DO WE DO). Mom has the flu ,and no one needs a doctor to tell her or the other people in the family, who have to resort to eating Kleenex. This works just OK in strep throat season when, even under the best of circumstances, the child with the sore throat might have a 50:50 shot at having strep even if his best friend had strep. The possibility that the person has the disease prior to the test being run is known as “pre-test probability.” If that number is very low, then the a positive test will almost certainly be a “false positive.” So, before the plane loads of Italians and Wuhanians debarked, we needed 0 tests. All of the coughing and shortness of breath was not Covid.

Once the first plane loads of feverish (and pre-feverish) folks from Wuhan and Milan were in America, lots of tests would have really been nice for multiple reasons. First, one of the ways to stop an infection for which there is no treatment is to catch the potentially infected people and quarantine them until the risk of spread is diminished. Had we kept these folks separated from the rest of America until we had a “true-negative” test, the virus would have never come here. Secondly, there is no way to distinguish this virus from the influenza virus, the parainfluenza virus, or any of the other viruses that cause fever, chills, shaking chills, and the rest of the symptoms associated with Covid-19. The difference is that Covid-19 kills people over 65 and is spread by people who don’t know they have it. A positive test (whether true or false) in combination with paid sick leave could have kept meat plant workers away from their colleagues, infected visitors away from their family member in the nursing home, and allowed patients with infection to be treated by an appropriately dressed care team.

The timeline for the test for the virus is as follows: The gene sequence was known on January 12. Once this is known a test can be created. The first known infected person got off an airplane on January 15. We only had 200 test kits made by February 4th but they had a really high (almost 100%) false positive rate. It was another month before the CDC would let commercial labs create their own test. By March 14th we were collecting specimens in Mobile and sending them to a commercial lab in Birmingham that had just gotten permission to run the swabs. Problem was that the results took 5 days to come back. It was several weeks before we could get a result back in the same day.

If everything works right (the person has the right swab stuck up his or her nose and put into the right liquid and sent to the right lab) the virus test allows us to tell people if they are currently shedding virus with excellent certainty (it is a “true positive”). If they have fever, it tells us that they have the Covid. If they have no fever it tells us they have a 50:50 shot at developing the Covid fever. Either way, it also tells us that they can give it to folks they live with, work with, or cough on in a nightclub. It allows us to tell them to wear a mask and stay away from folks for 14 days or until they test negative. Even if it turns out they had a “false-negative,” their being quarantined would save lives and allow live to go on for others.

What we lost by not having good virus testing is control of the disease. We had people coming to the hospital who were potentially (but not certainly) sick with the Covid. We had their family members and the hospital staff who helped them exposed to the Covid, who they then went home to their families. We had people who were dying anyway catch the Covid and give it to their caregivers and we had no clue that they had the Covid. We had people come to the Mardi Gras because they had a scheduled hotel room and cough on people at the parade who then, with a little headache and muscle aches, went to their job at the nursing home. It came to funerals in rural Georgia, Easter service in rural Alabama, and Veterans Nursing Home where it killed 22 of our greatest generation. It is now in every county in Alabama.

Where are we now with testing? We, as a country, have tested over 10 million people since March 8th and found 1.4 million folks with the Covid. Although it sounds like a lot, since Covid is in every nook and cranny of the country experts say we need to test up to 35 million folks A DAY to find everyone infected. We also need to test more than people with fever or headaches. We need to test people who have contact with those who are sick to find virus shedders who are not going to run a fever. We need to identify those people who are infected and have them sit out the next 14 days so the chain of infection can be broken.

But wait, you say, if I already had it, can’t I be free to move about the country without fear? The answer is yes, but I’m 99% sure that you haven’t. That, my friend, is the story for next time.

As states in the deep South and elsewhere are starting to open up from shelter-in-place orders I think we need to get some things straight.

Things that the virus is not:

  1. A deep state conspiracy. It was not created in a lab in Wuhan. It almost certainly is a naturally occuring coronavirus that moved from a bat to humans via an intermediate mammal.
  2. Going to magically go away. Very few people have immunity right now. Summer does not make this virus go away. We are stuck with it until 60% to 80% of Americans get it (culminating in about 1,500,000 dead Americans), we get a vaccine (unlikely in the next year) or we take stopping the spread of the virus seriously as other countries have done.
  3. That thing you had in January. It is almost certain that only 1% to 5% of the population in any place in America except New York City has been exposed to the virus based in antibody testing
  4. Just a bad “flu.” In a really bad flu year in the United States we have 61,000 deaths over the entire season. We have had at least 75,000 deaths from this virus in 2 months.
  5. Not going to hurt me. Randomly people die in car accidents. Randomly people die of this virus. Less randomly older and chronically ill people die of this virus when exposed.
  6. A plot by big pharma to harvest your healthcare dollars. This is a virus that is killing people. It is not activated by masks. It is spread through coughing droplets on others.

What the virus is…The virus is real.  It  came over from China (west coast) and Europe (east coast). It has almost certainly killed almost 100,000 people in this country so far although the death toll will be artificially low due to the way we categorize deaths (I know, I fill out death certificates all the time). It is almost certain that a medication will not help with mortality. If you get the virus, your risk of death depends on your age (very few under 65 die as compared to a lot over 80), your underlying health (those with chronic illness and/or obesity fair much worse than those who are basically healthy), and your exposure history (if you do not come in contact with droplets of spit contaminated with Covid-19, you will not catch it).

The way it came into the United States is a follows. Initially people got off an airplane from either China or Europe with the virus growing in their upper respiratory tract. They may have had a fever, cough and body aches. They may have developed a fever and body aches once off the plane. They may never have done so and cleared the virus. The travelers then went to an activity where there were a lot of other people. A scientific meeting in Boston, A jet setter party in Connecticut. Mardi Gras in New Orleans. They coughed on people at these places and a lot of them got infected. Problem was we were not testing those folks who were coming from infected areas. No tests.

First 100 deaths in the US didn’t happen until the last half of March. How did it happen? The people at  Mardi Gras, at meetings, in New York, the ones who were young and healthy then went and infected a couple of other people and mostly, the virus stopped there. Sometimes, before these people got sick (or even after), they went and did another group activity. They went to a community sing along. They went to a funeral and cried on their sister’s shoulder. They went to church and coughed on someone. At these events, though, there were older and sicker folks. When these folks got sick, they got really sick. Sometimes they went to the hospital, who couldn’t test them. When they got to the hospital there may have been lack of concern because it wasn’t in the community (again, no tests), and/or a lack of protective clothing. Health care workers would get exposed. They would get sick but, because they are troopers, would continue to work through the “flu.” If their job happened to be in a nursing home, many older people who were at risk would get exposed and some would die (either in the nursing home or in the hospital), many other health care workers would get exposed, and then many more people died. The workers in the nursing homes then go back to THEIR families and the cycle continues. Although, as the saying goes, we all have to die sometime, it doesn’t have to all be in the next month. Even now, we do not have enough tests, the ability to administer tests, or protective gear for folks caring for nursing home patients. About 1.5 million people live in nursing homes in this country. That will be a lot of deaths that don’t have to happen

So, the country is opening up and, in the words of the President, “some people will be affected badly.” Assuming you do not want to be the proximate cause (or the 2 degrees of separation cause) of someone’s Papa’s death, there are some things you can do:

  1. Wear a mask. If we get infected we may not know it for 3 or more days. A mask keeps us from infecting someone else who may have an underlying condition or just be older and more susceptible.
  2. Wash your hands or use hand sanitizer. This will keep you and others from getting it.
  3. Stay physically active. Outside is usually safe with social distancing.
  4. Stay away from and don’t hold gatherings of more than 10 people now and 50 people until there is a vaccine. There is clear evidence that social distancing works and when it goes away people die. Stay 6 feet away from folks you are not quarantining with.
  5. Stay home when possible. Remember, you don’t know if you will become sick 2 days from now
  6. Most importantly, stay home if you are sick. If you have a new loss of smell, cough, fever, shills, shaking chills, or shortness of breath but are otherwise healthy, don’t go out for 14 days.

Unlike many countries, we missed the opportunity to control this virus before is became endemic. If we follow the above measures, become much better at testing and protection of healthcare workers and first responders, and learn how to give up some freedom so that those infected can be isolated, then we can get control of our lives back with minimal loss of Meemees and Papas. The alternative is to lose 2,000,000 folks. Guess we each have some choices to make.

 

My first wife died almost 4 years ago, in April. She was 55 years old when she died. Her life story was remarkable in and of itself, one in which I was fortunate to play a part. Her story began, it turns out, with a natural experiment.

First, she was taken from her biological mother and placed in foster care for several months. Second, her adoptive parents were carefully selected. They were screened for resemblance (white but not too white), religion (not Catholic), and temperament.  Third, little Delphine had the full 1960’s data wipe. Her birth certificate was changed to reflect her adoptive parents and new name (Danielle). The date and size (I suppose) remained the same but the hospital, mother’s city of birth, father’s name, and any other detail was transferred over then attested to be the truth by the Orleans Parish registrar. She was a tabula rosa, existing to be filled out with the essence of Bev and Hank. She was one of 100,000 “closed adoptions” in 1961.

How did this experiment turn out? By the 1970’s, adoptees (mostly post WWII babies) were clamoring for personal information. Many were unhappy with their wiped identity. By the 1980s registries popped up and birth parents were allowed to register as were adoptees. By the 1990s most adoptions had some degree of openness. With the advent of 23 and Me, there were no secrets. Most adoptions now include some degree of openness.

Well, we really don’t know how the “taking away of babies and wiping them clean” experiment worked out because it wasn’t treated as an experiment. The societal belief  was that being taken out of a house where one is unwanted and being placed in a loving, nurturing environment would always be a good thing. Perhaps we should have looked more closely.

But a research brief published in October by the Institute for Family Studies threw a bit of cold water on this fantasy. The report, written by psychologist Nicholas Zill, was sobering: At the start of kindergarten, about one in four adopted children has a diagnosed disability, twice the rate of children being raised by both biological parents. Adopted children were significantly likelier than birth children to have behavior and learning problems; teachers reported they were worse at paying attention in class, and less able to persevere on difficult tasks.

In Danielle’s case, she found her birth mother (Pat) when we were in our 30s and had just moved back to Mobile. Or, rather, her birth family found her. At the reunion (on Royal Street during Mardi Gras), I knew that the slate was never wiped clean, despite the efforts of the state of Louisiana. Where Bev was shrewd, Pat was open (like Danielle). Where Bev was practical, Pat was creative (like Danielle). Where Bev was closed, Pat was open. Where Bev used soaps whose smells I found irritating, Pat used THE SAME SOAP AS DANIELLE. Oddly enough, Pat was 55 years old when she died.

The tabula rosa thing was not studied as an experiment. Why study something we knew “felt right?”  The closest science came to looking at this was the Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart. These investigators look at closed adoptions where twins were taken from families and raised as singletons. They have found that genetic factors appear to influence personality, mental, and activity-level changes as adults become older, to the tune of half. Yup, turns out you can only wipe the slate 50% clean.

One example of the amazing similarity of twins reared apart is the so-called “Jim twins”. These twins were adopted at the age of four weeks. Both of the adopting couples, unknown to each other, named their son James. Upon reunion of the twins when they were 39 years old, Jim and Jim have learned that:

  • Both twins are married to women named Betty and divorced from women named Linda.
  • One has named his first son James Alan while the other named his first son James Allan.
  • Both twins have an adopted brother whose name is Larry.
  • Both named their pet dog “Toy.”
  • Both had some law-enforcement training and had been a part-time deputy sheriff in Ohio.
  • Each did poorly in spelling and well in math.
  • Each did carpentry, mechanical drawing, and block lettering.
  • Each vacation in Florida in the same three-block-long beach area.
  • Both twins began suffering from tension headaches at eighteen, gained ten pounds at the same time, and are six feet tall and 180 pounds.

Closed adoption have not stopped. This is because when people look at a newborn they don’t see a thing half full of mom and dad but believe they are viewing a tabula rosa, despite evidence to the contrary.

Why think about natural studies? Because we are about to embark on one in this country around Covid-19 spread. What we know is that, left unchecked, every person with Covid-19 infects about 3 other folks and they infect 3 other folks, and so on until the whole world is infected and about 2% of the world is dead. That is, unless, the person who is infected stays home AND the person who is not infected doesn’t come into contact with an infected person. This breakage in the chain of infection has occurred because of shelter in place severe social distancing. Currently, this is a nationwide effort. As we reach the end of this phase, we are about to see 50 states going in different directions. The East Coast and West Coast states, for the most part, seem poised to maintain distancing for a bit longer, test a lot of folks, and chase down those that are infected to keep them from restarting the chain of infection. We on the Gulf Coast seem poised to demand an end to social distancing, eschew testing, hit the beaches and the baseball stadiums, and blame Barack Obama for the destruction of the economy.

Many are looking at this Covid-19 crisis through a different lens than I. What I see is a broken the chain of infection. What I see is a virus that is deadly and lurking, waiting for the chain of infection to be re-activated. We are about to embark on a natural experiment. Those of us whose neighbors look around and see conspiracy may bring Covid-19 deaths back into our nursing homes. I only hope we are measuring what happens.

 

My, how time flies when you are having fun. As president of our national organization of Family Medicine Department chairs, I had the opportunity to lead our group in a discussion regarding the response to Covid-19. As a work product (a great meeting BINGO word) we created a to do list for America (found here). We are now 3 weeks, 500,000 cases, and 20,000 additional deaths from the publication of this work product. How did we do?

  1. 4 week shelter in place order for all jurisdictions – as of April 7th, at least 316 million people in at least 42 statesthree countiesnine citiesthe District of Columbia and Puerto Rico are being urged to stay home. This is up from 9 states on March 23. While correlation does not prove causality, at least we were on the leading edge of recommendations. It is believed that this action saved (or will save) over a million lives in this country.
  2. Training and deploying a cadre of individuals capable of contact tracing and dramatically increasing access to testing – This will be vital to the SUCCESSFUL reopening of the country. As of today we have tested 3,000,000 Americans over the course of the outbreak. While a big number, in a country of 325 million people, not so many. We need to test close to 2,000,000 folks PER WEEK. We need to test people who have fevers. We need to test people who have been with someone with a fever. We need to test people who work in nursing homes. We also need to, once we find a positive, go and make sure that they are quarantined AND THEN TEST THEIR CONTACTS. This is a skill set that many in public health have allowed to atrophy since infectious disease became unsexy. If we were good at this, syphilis would not be a problem. For Covid control if we were to open the country, everybody would need to be tested approximately every 2 weeks with adequate investigators for the positives.
  3. Adequate personal protective equipment. – As someone who trains medical learners, this is near and dear to my heart. It is unclear how many health care workers, first responders, even grocery workers have been infected in their line of work. This is due to a broken supply chain, inadequate planning, and an inability to plan for the “unthinkable.” The CDC, on April 3rd, issued guidance on reusing “single use” equipment, One can only hope that we are working to adequately protect our health care workers. While there are many feel good stories about folks repurposing their plants to make eye protectors, there are many more about the lack of PPE and the fear that care delivery workers carry home with them.

So, now what? Hopefully we will continue to shelter in place, obtain testing and case finding to allow us to open the country, and obtain adequate PPE to protect vital workers. Fact is, Covid-19 is a disease that has no effective treatment and when fully manifested does not respond well to supportive care. It kills very few people in their 30s, more in their 40s, and so on until the population gets to be around 80, where 20% of those who develop an infection will die. For most of these older folks, besides protecting them from the virus we cannot alter the course of the disease

What can we do? To quote one of America’s great physicians, Sir William quote Osler, “Ask not what disease the person has, but rather what person the disease has”. The reality is we as caregivers are back in the era of “The Doctor.” I took some time today to read the bio’s of the Covid victims and I recommend you all do the same. Honor the victims. Let’s take some time to remember the people we care for, despite the isolation.

This is not about an invisible enemy except in that if you remain isolated you will not encounter it. This is about an insidious disease that is brought to our patients because of the efficient way we care for them (nursing homes, group homes), the way we ask them to work (low wages, no health insurance, limited childcare, no sick leave), and the limited information we give them (let’s reopen the economy). We need to fight THOSE enemies.

 

Screen Shot 2020-03-25 at 1.55.31 PM

The group of academic family physicians that I have the honor of leading this year have found themselves in the midst of a Covid 19 outbreak. Representing all 50 states, these academic leaders are working in some of the largest, most modern academic health centers in the world. Academic health centers that, unfortunately, are not prepared for the challenge that is just now hitting the coasts but will soon spread across the country.

The preamble to this crisis goes back 30 years. As hospitals have tried to maximize their profits, they began using “just-in-time” inventory. Toyota, it turns out, does not have a warehouse for parts. Instead it gets the carburetor (or whatever parts cars have in them now) delivered at the exact moment the car rolls to that point on the assembly line. Hospitals began using the same, getting only the masks or other equipment they need for the next week from the plant (in China) rather that maintain a warehouse. Well, also only having enough hospital beds for people who need them. Toyota never needed to plan on all of America needing a car within the same 2 month period. Hospitals, turns out, also never planned for Americans to get sick all at once. Guess now we know.

We might have overcome the lack of protective gear except for one problem. If you are treating all of America for a virus that acts like 5 other viruses except it kills you, the only way to “not going to die” people from “just might die” people is by testing for the bad virus. If you know the patient has the bad virus, you can isolate him or her and protect the health care workers more accurately. America, with the best funded health systems in the world, botched the test.

If the country could have accurately tracked the spread of the virus, hospitals could have executed their pandemic plans, girding themselves by allocating treatment rooms, ordering extra supplies, tagging in personnel, or assigning specific facilities to deal with COVID-19 cases.

We have less protective equipment, fewer hospital beds, and more chronically ill people than Italy (7503 deaths to date, 743 last night) and Spain (3434 deaths to date, 514 last night). We did not spend the last year preparing for this surge and, by screwing up the testing, we probably have 200,000 infected people going around infecting others. If you look at the cities where things are bad, they are also cities where either lots of people live (New York, Los Angeles) or cities that had a lot of recent visitors from all over (Mardi Gras in New Orleans). It takes about 4 days to know if you are infected (with something….is it the flu? I just feel a little achy) and if you are going to get really sick it happens on about day 8. So now what?

  1. Sheltering in place. What we know is that if people who are infected limit themselves to limited contact with a small group people, the virus “dies out.” It takes enough time for the virus to finish with patient 0 (the first sick person) and the 2 other people who will likely get sick from that person as well. This virus is spread through coughing, sneezing, and otherwise having fluid spewed. 15 days is not nearly enough time to reduce the number of infected people. Even of only 5% of Americans get this virus (17,000,000) and 10% need intensive care we would need almost 1,000,000 ventilators. This is about 700,000 less than we have now. Without these ventilators people die, with them they live.
  2. Testing and contact tracing. Once we stop sheltering in place, the virus will still be with us. The countries that have successfully reopened have continued to test their populations and, once a positive is found, identified all of the folks they have come in contact with and placed them in “shelter in place” for 2 weeks as well. We not only have not invested in protective gear, we have not invested in this very basic public health workforce.
  3. Adequate personal protective equipment. 40% of those who became ill in China were associated with health care delivery, either as care providers or the families of care providers. Protecting health care workers is vital. Sending health care workers out to potentially die is unconscionable.

So, here we are. One choice is to shelter in place for the next month or three, put up with occasional outbreak which gets tamped down, and delay until a vaccine is developed. Another choice is to throw our hands in the air, declare this too hard, and sit back while 4,000,000 die a potentially preventable death. My colleagues and I believe the first choice is the only choice. Please discuss with the policymakers in your states.

Archives